FodScale

← All posts · Nov 2, 2026

Low-FODMAP sweeteners: honey, sugar, maple and the sugar-free trap

Sweet things are one of the more confusing corners of the low-FODMAP diet. Honey sounds natural and is high. Plain white sugar sounds like the villain and is low. "Sugar-free" sweets can be some of the worst offenders. It all makes sense once you know which sugars count as FODMAPs.

The rule: fructose needs glucose

Fructose on its own is a FODMAP when there is more of it than glucose. Glucose helps the gut absorb fructose, so foods with roughly equal amounts are usually fine, while foods with a surplus of fructose ("excess fructose") are not.

That one rule sorts most sweeteners.

Low FODMAP in normal amounts

  • Table sugar (sucrose). One molecule of sucrose is one glucose joined to one fructose, a perfect balance. Monash says white sugar rarely causes IBS symptoms and can be eaten in moderation (Monash, sugar confusion). Brown sugar is the same sugar with some molasses.
  • Pure maple syrup. Monash lists it alongside table sugar and rice malt syrup as a low-FODMAP option (Monash, high and low FODMAP foods). Check it is pure maple syrup, not a "pancake syrup" built on corn syrup.
  • Rice malt syrup, which Monash lists in the same group.
  • Plain corn syrup, which is mostly glucose. Do not confuse it with high-fructose corn syrup (FODMAP Friendly, label reading).

High FODMAP

  • Honey. Most honey is about 40% fructose to 30% glucose, so it carries excess fructose. FODMAP Friendly found clover honey high even at a 10 g serve (FODMAP Friendly, clover honey).
  • Agave syrup, which both Monash and FODMAP Friendly list among the high-fructose sweeteners (FODMAP Friendly, high and low FODMAP foods).
  • High-fructose corn syrup (HFCS). The common type, HFCS-55, is 55% fructose, so fructose outweighs glucose. It is very common in American soft drinks and rare in Australia, and Monash suggests avoiding it during elimination and testing it at reintroduction (Monash, HFCS). This is why FodScale flags an ordinary American soda in a recipe, unless the recipe offers a diet version or sparkling water.
  • Fruit juice concentrates, such as apple and pear, used to sweeten "no added sugar" products.

The sugar-free trap: polyols

Many sugar-free sweets, gums and mints are sweetened with polyols, the sugar alcohols. They are FODMAPs. Sorbitol and mannitol occur naturally in some fruit and vegetables, while xylitol, maltitol and isomalt are added to gum, mints and diabetic products (Monash, what are polyols). In a Monash study, 10 g of sorbitol or mannitol was enough to significantly raise symptoms in people with IBS (Monash, sweeteners). On a label, look for words ending in "-itol" and for isomalt.

Erythritol is where the sources disagree. FODMAP Friendly says it is not high FODMAP because it is well absorbed (FODMAP Friendly, sweeteners), while Monash still groups it with the polyols to watch. If you want to use it, test your own tolerance.

Swapping in recipes

  • Honey or agave to maple syrup is the easiest swap: similar texture, similar sweetness, and it works in dressings, glazes and baking.
  • Honey to table sugar works in most baking; add a splash of liquid if the batter looks dry.
  • A recipe's own alternative is usually best. If a recipe already says "honey or sugar", use the sugar, because the person who wrote it has tested it.

Being low FODMAP does not make sugar a health food, of course. It just means it is unlikely to be the thing that sets off your gut.

FodScale applies published portion science mechanically. It is not medical advice and does not know your triggers; a dietitian can help you through elimination and reintroduction.

Save my data

Your saved recipes and reviews live on this device. Sign in once and they follow you to your phone and computer. No password: a link in your inbox or your Google account is the whole login.

Device ID: